Friends and neighbors,
I have a very important update on healthcare in Faribault. As many of you know, Allina Health is planning to merge with Sutter Health. Minnesota’s Attorney General has the authority to review healthcare mergers and go to court to block them if they aren’t in the public interest. In practice, that leverage is used to negotiate protections.
This summer, I worked with all of you to collect testimony on the importance of local access to care. Allina runs our main hospital in town. Research has often found that hospital consolidation raises prices, and that rural hospitals can lose services after an acquisition.
Many of you filled out my survey or spoke at the Attorney General’s forum here in Faribault. In my written comments to the Attorney General’s office, featuring survey results, my main request was a written commitment that names Faribault's hospital as a protected site.
Well, today the Attorney General announced a 10-year oversight agreement with Allina and Sutter, and Faribault is explicitly named in it as one of the hospitals covered by its service commitments. That is a win.
So what does this agreement do for care in Faribault? Faribault is named as one of seven rural Allina hospitals that must keep 10 core services for five years. Those services are primary care, cancer care, intensive care, emergency room, mental health, cardiovascular, stroke, women’s health OBGYN, orthopedics, and surgery.
For 10 years, Allina in Minnesota must keep charity care, keep financial assistance for patients up to 275% of the federal poverty level, and keep taking Medicare and Medicaid. Existing union contracts will be honored. Sutter’s $2.15 billion capital commitment is binding and includes technology and equipment upgrades at rural hospitals. There are several reporting mechanisms to ensure transparency over the next ten years.
Now, in my opinion, this agreement falls short in a few key areas.
First and foremost, there are no new limits on price increases. This would have been a rare opportunity where the public could have secured new cost protections in healthcare. This agreement does not address the cost increases that typically accompany a healthcare merger. That is a missed opportunity and I think it is a real shame.
You may see reports about $150 million for rural health and more than $50 million for workforce. Those aren’t part of the binding agreement. They’re in a separate letter from Allina and Sutter, which calls them “statements of intent and aspiration.” I hope those aspirations come to fruition, but nothing requires them to follow through on those intentions.
Then there are parts of the agreement that I find somewhat open to interpretation when it comes to how things will work for us in Faribault. I am working to get clarification from the Attorney General's office on those specifics.
So there are real protections for Faribault in this agreement. My main concern is that the protections are only as strong as the enforcement. I’m still researching what tools will be available for reporting any loss of services over the next five years. Once I know what’s available, I’ll update you and help you access those tools.
Many people told me Faribault’s voice wouldn’t matter here. That there was no real chance to make change. Well, we asked for Faribault to be protected in writing. And it is. This gives us the chance to make sure it is protected in practice. We would not have written commitments to leverage without this agreement.
We successfully pulled one lever of change: the protections in this merger agreement. Our job now is to find the next lever, and the one after that, and the one after that. This is the process of self-governance, and it’s what I’ll keep doing as your Rice County Commissioner once I’m sworn in in January.
Thank you for trusting me with your healthcare stories. There is more work to do, and I look forward to getting it done together.
In solidarity,
Sam Temple